Episode Transcript
[00:00:01] Critical Scholars who Keep the Faith Guest post by Dale Allison Read by John Paul Middlesworth introduced by Bart Ehrman I frequently get asked how any highly informed scholar of the Bible, knowing about biblical contradictions, historical mistakes, false claims, forged writings and so on could still be a committed Christian. I usually respond that it certainly is possible and that most critical scholars of the New Testament are in fact Christians.
[00:00:31] Some people then tell me they don't believe it. They think scholars like that must just be faking it, or that it just doesn't make sense.
[00:00:38] So I've asked a few top level biblical scholars to explain how they themselves do it. How do they manage it inside their own heads? And how would they explain it to themselves and possibly others?
[00:00:50] The first to respond to my request was Dale Allison, Richard J. Dearborn professor of New Testament at Princeton Theological Seminary.
[00:00:58] Dale is widely recognized as one of the top New Testament scholars in the world. Highly erudite, widely published, very influential in the field and among lay readers, and as knowledgeable as they come.
[00:01:10] Here's how he explains how it works for him, this balance of critical knowledge and Christian faith.
[00:01:16] His answer in a It's a long standing part of the Christian tradition to be fully knowledgeable about the Bible and recognize its serious problems, but also be a believer.
[00:01:27] Feel free to comment.
[00:01:28] Because of a crazily taxing schedule, Dale will not be able to reply directly to questions, but read and enjoy.
[00:01:36] I go to church, pray for others, hope for a life beyond this one, and have studied the Bible my entire adult life. I've not done these things because I believe the Bible to be doctrinally inerrant or free of contradictions, or unburdened by historical problems.
[00:01:53] It is none of those things, as all sorts of Christians before me have recognized.
[00:01:58] Origen, the third century theologian, observed that at many points the four Gospels do not agree.
[00:02:04] The evangelists, he wrote, sometimes altered things which from the eye of history occurred otherwise. They could speak of something that happened in one place as if it happened in another, or of what happened at a certain time as if it had happened at another time.
[00:02:20] And they introduced into what was spoken in a certain way some changes of their own.
[00:02:25] He inferred that their truth cannot reside in the material letter and that the spiritual truth was often preserved, one might say, in the material falsehood.
[00:02:38] The great Protestant hero Martin Luther was even more radical. He didn't like Revelation and would have omitted it from his translation of the New Testament had he thought he could get away with it.
[00:02:49] He also much disliked the Book of James.
[00:02:51] He once confided that sometimes he felt like throwing Jimmy into the fire.
[00:02:56] Luther further thought that Mark 13 is actually misleading because, as he inferred from comparison with Luke, it doesn't preserve the order of the words as Jesus spoke them. Although more conservative about the Bible, John Calvin also sat loose on some things. He recognized, for example, that Matthew 5, 7, Sermon on the Mount, and Matthew 10, the missionary discourse, are artificial compilations.
[00:03:22] According to the reformer, Matthew, for thematic reasons, gathered into his discourses words that at one time were scattered, words that Jesus originally uttered on diverse occasions. In other words, the Sermon on the Mount is not really a sermon of Jesus. It is rather, in an important sense that Matthew's creation long before Calvin, Augustine admitted that we are certainly under no necessity of supporting that because it an event in the Gospels is recorded after a certain event, it must also have happened in actual matter of fact after that event.
[00:03:58] He also recognized that harmonization is not always possible when contemplating the different words the disciples speak during the episode of the stilling of the storm on the Sea of Galilee.
[00:04:08] Lord, save us. We are perishing as in Matthew. Teacher, do you not care that we are perishing as in Mark?
[00:04:15] Master, master, we are perishing as in Luke. Calvin remarked, it is not worth inquiring which of them records what was actually said to Christ.
[00:04:25] And it really makes no difference whether the disciples uttered one of these three versions or other words which none of the evangelists recorded.
[00:04:34] Recognizing historical and theological problems with Scripture is nothing new under the sun. I am in good company.
[00:04:41] Two more quick thoughts. First, I'm confident that none of my textbooks in high school or college were free of typos and errors. And my history books in particular, as is apparent to me in hindsight, got a lot of things very wrong.
[00:04:56] I still learned history.
[00:04:57] I also know that my high school trigonometry textbook had lots of mistakes in it because our teacher collected them as we noticed them so that he could forward them to the publisher who would, he hoped, subtract the mistakes we found from the next edition.
[00:05:12] Nonetheless, my classmates and I learned trigonometry.
[00:05:16] There is no field of human knowledge that requires infallible books before education is possible.
[00:05:21] Why should it be different with the Bible and theology?
[00:05:24] What a strange requirement.
[00:05:27] Second, we have learned an awful lot about everything in recent centuries.
[00:05:31] The Bible is not the exception to the rule, and it makes no sense to continue to read it without taking full account of everything that has come to light from archaeology, comparative religion, geology, the study of ancient near east religions, and whatnot.
[00:05:45] To disregard knowledge is to be ignorant. Who wants to admit to sponsoring that?
[00:05:51] Dale C. Allison, Jr. Princeton Theological Seminary.