Questi ons About the Trinity, the Incarnation, and the Star of Bethlehem

November 12, 2026 • 00:05:53
Questi ons About the Trinity, the Incarnation, and the Star of Bethlehem
Ehrman Blog Daily Post Podcasts
Questi ons About the Trinity, the Incarnation, and the Star of Bethlehem

Nov 12 2026 | 00:05:53

/

Show Notes

Bart answers questions of the meanings of various biblical passages.

Read by John Paul Middlesworth.

View Full Transcript

Episode Transcript

[00:00:01] Questions about the Trinity, the Incarnation, and the Star of Bethlehem answered by Bart Ehrman Read by John Paul Middlesworth Here are some more of the many intriguing queries I have recently received from inquiring minds inside the heads of blog readers. [00:00:16] Question On Friday evening I was at Wheaton College for a presentation by Ayaan Hirsi Ali, famous Muslim apostate and public intellectual, and Darrell Bock of Dallas Theological Seminary. He quoted a verse, Matthew 28:19, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. I thought of you because I thought I learned on this blog that the only reference to the Trinity in the NT was in one of the John Epistles. Is this usage here not sufficiently trinitarian to scholars? [00:00:50] Ah, right. [00:00:51] Matthew 28:19 certainly does name the Father, Son, and Spirit, but that's not the doctrine of the Trinity. The doctrine is not that all three exist. It is about how they specifically relate to each other. The orthodox view that developed by the end of the fourth century consists of several affirmations. [00:01:10] 1. That the three father, son, and Spirit are all equally God, fully God of the same substance, CO Eternal, CO Powerful 2 and that they are three distinct persons 3 and that there is only one God. [00:01:27] In short, three distinct persons, all equal, no hierarchy among them, and together only one God. [00:01:35] Matthew doesn't say any of that, so he is not expressing the doctrine of the Trinity. That's not unusual. Even in the early centuries of Christianity, there were lots of thinkers who agree that Father, Son, and Spirit were all in some sense God, but they did not also claim, for example, that they were fully equal in every way. [00:01:56] My note this question is based on a passage in Philippians 2 that begins a description of Christ by saying that even though he was in the form of God, he did not regard equality with God something to be grasped, but he emptied himself and took on the form of a slave. [00:02:13] And now the question. [00:02:15] At Catholic Mass on Sunday, the priest parsed the Philippians Christological Hymn and said the word translated as grasped can in the Greek also mean held on to. [00:02:27] Naturally this would be the received reading in the Church. But wondering if you agree, I asked the priest about his mastery and he confirmed he personally had only elementary Greek. [00:02:38] I didn't challenge his reading. Nice guy. [00:02:43] Yes, it's an important and debated issue. Is Paul saying that before he became a human, Christ did not strive to be equal with God? He didn't grasp after something he didn't have, or that he chose not to remain equal? He didn't cling on to what he already had. [00:03:00] The term in Greek can mean either. [00:03:03] Sometimes it means to hold on to something you already have, and at other times it means snatch something you don't have. [00:03:10] It's only by the context in which the word is used that you can tell which it means. [00:03:15] In this case, I think the context is decisive. A few verses later, Paul says that after Jesus submitted to crucifixion, God highly exalted him, possibly with the nuance of more highly exalted him, and at that point not before God gave him the name that is above every name, Christ, so that all creation will bow before him and worship him as God himself. [00:03:42] That clearly suggests to me that he did not have equality before that. [00:03:46] Some readers theologians are reluctant to say that because it can be seen as compromising the doctrine of the Trinity that Christ was coeternal with God and from all eternity equal with him. [00:03:59] Leaving aside the physical absurdity of a star moving and hovering over a particular house somewhere I've heard it posited that a comet or nova or something in the constellation of Leo, which, being a lion, perhaps was symbolically taken to mean Judah. [00:04:15] I'm not saying the Magi story is plausible, but I can imagine it being invented later for support. [00:04:21] If it was invented based on a real astrological event, the 7 to 5 BCE might be useful in establishing that Jesus lived to be anywhere from 31 to 43 years old. [00:04:32] Since we know the dates when Pilate was governor 26 to 36 CE. [00:04:37] Response yes, there have been many attempts to explain the passage by some kind of natural phenomenon. One problem is that the author of Matthew, living 80 to 85 years later in a different part of the world, would not have known what happened in the sky that day or year in Jerusalem or Bethlehem. Apart from the fact you point out that no astronomical phenomenon could possibly correspond with the text, it's probably better simply to say that everyone knew of unusual celestial events and many thought they portended things on earth, such as the comet taken to be Julius Caesar ascending to the realm of the gods. [00:05:14] In this case, the author is actually explaining a prophetic fulfillment. [00:05:18] Usually he is quite explicit about something at Jesus birth that fulfills Scripture. Mother was a virgin, he was born in Bethlehem, he went to Egypt, etc. [00:05:27] Here, though he is subtle. Jesus is fulfilling the prophecy of Numbers 24:17 I shall see him, but not now. I shall behold him, but not nigh. There shall come a star out of Jacob, and a scepter shall rise out of Israel and shall smite the corners of Moab.

Other Episodes

Episode

January 07, 2024 • 00:06:45
Episode Cover

How to Botch a Bible Translation (Because of Inclusive Language)

When the right idea gets the wrong result... Read by Ken Teutsch.

Listen

Episode

August 16, 2025 • 00:06:20
Episode Cover

Why Does the Author of 1 Peter Sound Like Paul Instead of Peter?

The author of 1 Peter has different concerns from the disciple Peter, as Dr. Ehrman emphasizes. Read by John Paul Middlesworth.

Listen

Episode

August 09, 2026 • 00:12:00
Episode Cover

Prophetic Condemnation of Jews Within Judaism Before Jesus

Read by Ken Teutsch.

Listen