Jesus and the Trolley Problem - Platinum Post by Douglas Wadeson MD

November 13, 2026 • 00:08:21
Jesus and the Trolley Problem - Platinum Post by Douglas Wadeson MD
Ehrman Blog Daily Post Podcasts
Jesus and the Trolley Problem - Platinum Post by Douglas Wadeson MD

Nov 13 2026 | 00:08:21

/

Show Notes

The Trolley Problem is a well-known thought experiment, but does it have any application in the real world? In this Platinum Post, Douglas Wadeson considers whether anything Jesus said or did is relevant, and how the Problem can help us to understand modern dilemmas.

Read by Steve McCabe.

View Full Transcript

Episode Transcript

[00:00:01] Jesus and the Trolley Problem A Platinum Post by Douglas Wadeson, M.D. [00:00:07] i'm pleased to post this new Platinum post by Platinum member Douglas Wadeson. For all of you other Platinums, this one's a bit of a brain teaser. Good luck working it out and may you never have to in practice. [00:00:19] In philosophy, a standard thought experiment is the trolley problem. [00:00:24] There are variations, but the basic premise starts with a runaway trolley car that's heading down the track toward a group of five people. [00:00:31] There's a switch in front of you which will divert the trolley to a side track on which there is only one person. [00:00:37] Should you pull the switch, knowing that your action will cause that one person to die, but the five will live? [00:00:43] No. Yelling at the five to get off the track isn't allowed. [00:00:46] Some would argue that allowing five to live is the better choice. So pull the switch. Others would say that pulling the switch makes you an active participant in the death of the one, so that's not morally right. [00:00:59] Yet others would counter that since you have the switch available to you, doing nothing is still a choice and you are a participant in someone's death either way. [00:01:07] So what would you do? [00:01:10] Now, let's add some complications. [00:01:13] Suppose there are only two on the main track versus one on the side track. [00:01:17] Would you act to kill one in order to save two? [00:01:21] Suppose the five are senior citizens near the end of their lives and the one on the side track is a child with his life still ahead of him. [00:01:29] Would that change your decision? [00:01:31] What if you saw that the five were Secret Service agents and the one was the President of the United States? Would that influence your decision? [00:01:39] Would it depend on who was the President at the time? How about this one? The one on the side track is your child or it's another family member, while the other five are strangers. Who do you save in that situation? [00:01:52] An interesting variation is that instead of a switch, there's a large fat man standing next to you. [00:01:58] Pushing him onto the track would surely stop the trolley and save the five. Would you push him onto the track? [00:02:04] Some people who say they would pull the switch will balk at the idea of pushing a person onto the track in order to save the five. Even though the outcome is just the same. It just feels wrong to actively push someone onto the track, even though they could argue that the actions are morally equivalent. [00:02:21] Now suppose in the original scenario, you chose to pull the switch, killing one, but saving five. [00:02:27] You make peace with that decision, knowing that five were saved. [00:02:31] You believe it was a correct moral decision. [00:02:34] The next day, there's an explosion at the train yard, a speeding train derails and many people are killed. And it turns out that the five were terrorists planning this attack and the one on the side track was a government agent following them in order to stop the attack. [00:02:48] Does that change the correctness or the morality of your action? Using your decision the previous day, do you now share responsibility in the deaths of the many? How could you know? Since we cannot know the ultimate outcome of our actions, should we always choose to do nothing and let fate take its course? [00:03:05] That doesn't seem quite right. Or does the inability to know the ultimate outcome exonerate us as long as we meant well when we acted? [00:03:14] I'm sure you can make up your own variation of this trolley problem. Try it. It's fun. [00:03:19] But let's get to the title of this article. What would Jesus do in this Scenario? Do his teachings have any relevance to the trolley problem? [00:03:27] Take a moment to come up with your own answer. [00:03:31] Some would answer that yes, there is a passage in the Gospels that applies. [00:03:35] It's found with interesting variations. In Mark 5, Matthew 9 and Luke 8, Jesus is asked to go and heal a young girl. [00:03:45] On his way, a woman with a long standing bleeding problem touches him in order to be healed. [00:03:51] Jesus stops and talks with the woman and in the meantime the girl dies. [00:03:56] Undaunted, Jesus proceeds to the girl and he raises her back to life. [00:04:02] Now some argue that this story shows that every life is sacred and precious to Jesus and doesn't make value judgments about which life is more important. [00:04:10] I don't think that this story really applies to the Crowley situation. [00:04:14] First, it's one life versus another, not one life against five. [00:04:19] Second, even if it shows that Jesus values every life, then do not five lives have value? More value? [00:04:26] Third, Jesus doesn't really have to make a choice in this story. He knows he's going to heal them both. [00:04:33] Another story sometimes applied is Jesus being tempted by Satan in the wilderness. [00:04:38] Satan offers Jesus all the kingdoms of the world if you will bow down and worship him. [00:04:43] Of course, Jesus refuses, but wouldn't that have saved many lives throughout history? [00:04:49] Wasn't that a good deal that Jesus should have accepted to save all those lives? [00:04:54] But of course, Satan is depicted as the author of lies. Expecting Satan to honor that promise is like expecting a $5,000 check after the midterms. [00:05:04] Besides, Jesus knows that he's going to save people by dying for them. That's not an option in the trolley problem. Sacrificing yourself is not allowed. You have to sacrifice others. [00:05:15] Of course Jesus said love one another. And he quoted the commandment do not murder in Mark 10:19. [00:05:22] But does that help with the trolley problem? [00:05:25] If you love the one, shouldn't you also love the five? [00:05:28] Is pulling the switch equivalent to the murder of the one? But then isn't failing to pull the switch equivalent to murder of the five? [00:05:35] Which is the most loving thing to do? Does either choice constitute murder, either of 1 or of 5? [00:05:42] You might think that these are all just abstract philosophical mind games, but there are real world applications. When there is large scale tragedy, emergency room physicians have to triage the patients and decide who to try to save first. [00:05:56] Do you pass over the older victim to treat a younger one? [00:05:59] What if the older one is more likely to survive because the child's injuries are more severe? [00:06:04] What if the older patient is the president and the younger one a nobody? It gets complicated. [00:06:12] Here's a modern day application. [00:06:14] Self driving cars are with us and they're on our roads. What do you program it to do in the situation where a collision seems inevitable, say a group of children are out into the road? [00:06:25] Steering left hits one child, steering right hits three. What should the car do? [00:06:32] What if one child is in the road, sure to get hit, but there are more children on either side that might get hit? If you steer around the one, do you program it to run over the one or to take a chance on hitting the others in order to save the one? [00:06:45] A city bus pulls out in front of the car, but swerving to the left will mean hitting a school bus. [00:06:51] What if hitting the school bus seems to be the safest option to protect the car occupant? What should the car do? [00:06:57] Somebody's programming these cars. What are the criteria that they are using? It matters. [00:07:05] There are other real world situations. [00:07:08] What if you believe that a regime is developing weapons of mass destruction which will be a great threat to world peace? Does that justify initiating a war in which, you know, civilians will be killed, including women and children? [00:07:21] Are you willing to see some people killed now, including your soldiers and their children, in the hope that more people will be saved in the long run? That's the trolley problem on a more global scale and with real lives at stakeholders. [00:07:34] Fortunately, most of us won't be faced with that kind of decision except in the voting booth. But we may have to make a split second decision about which way to turn the car when a child runs into the road. And there are many little decisions and it can affect the lives of many, like should I use this money to buy a new smartphone or donate the money to bart's blog to help people in need. Life is full of decisions that directly or indirectly affect the lives of others. What criteria do we use to make these decisions? So what would Jesus do with the trolley problem? Miraculously, stopping the trolley doesn't count. [00:08:06] Do his teachings help us with the problem or not? [00:08:10] Leave a comment and tell us what you would choose to do in the trolley problem or what teachings of Jesus you would apply to the situation.

Other Episodes

Episode 0

May 27, 2021 • 00:56:20
Episode Cover

Gold Member Q&A - May 2021

Dr Ehrman answers questions from Gold and Platinum members.

Listen

Episode

September 15, 2026 • 00:10:48
Episode Cover

Pins, Gates, and Why Jesus Was Not a Caplitalist

Read by Ken Teutsch.

Listen

Episode

December 11, 2025 • 00:04:27
Episode Cover

My Birdbrain View of Agnosticism

Bird watching leads Bart to thoughts about other minds. Read by John Paul Middlesworth.

Listen